Cars and vans › Brakes › Brake drag › Causes

Wheel cylinder, shoes or adjuster

A cause of brake drag on drum brakes only, including the small parking brake drum that sits inside the rear discs of some cars and vans.

A drum brake works from the inside out. Two curved brake shoes sit inside a drum that turns with the wheel. When you press the pedal, fluid pressure pushes the two pistons of the wheel cylinder outwards, and they press the shoes against the drum. When you let go, strong return springs pull the shoes back together and push the pistons home. The shoes rest on the backing plate, the steel plate that carries the whole assembly, and between them sits an adjuster, usually a threaded strut turned by a toothed star wheel, which sets how far the shoes rest from the drum. On many cars it lengthens by itself as the linings wear, while on others it is only ever set by hand, as on the Mercedes Sprinter's parking brake1. The parking brake uses the same shoes: a lever inside the drum spreads them mechanically when a cable pulls on it. Under the car an equalizer, a small rocker on a spring, splits the single front cable from the hand lever into one cable for each rear wheel and shares the pull between them.

The brake can only let go if every one of these parts moves back. A wheel cylinder whose pistons have rusted in place keeps the shoes out, and so does an adjuster that is set too tight or return springs that have gone weak. The fault can also lie on the parking brake side: a cable that sticks in its sheath, or an equalizer or lever that rusts and no longer returns, keeps pulling on the shoes after you have released the hand lever. In each case the shoes keep rubbing on the drum while you drive.

This page also applies to cars and vans with disc brakes at the rear whose parking brake is a small drum brake inside the hat of the rear disc. The Mercedes Sprinter and VW LT of the same era are built this way2,3, and so are the Subaru Tribeca, Toyota 4Runner, Highlander and Sienna, and the 1969 Corvette, according to their owners4. On those vehicles the parking brake shoes, their adjuster and the cable mechanism can all cause drag, while the disc side has its own causes, such as seized slide pins. If a wheel has neither a drum nor a drum parking brake, this cause does not apply to it, and the other causes of brake drag are the place to look.

How it shows up

Because the parking brake works on both rear wheels at once, a fault in its equalizer or front cable can heat both rear wheels equally while the fronts stay cool. A Sprinter owner found both rear brakes almost too hot to touch after 250 km of motorway, with the fronts only a little above hand warm, and suspected the parking brake for exactly that reason, since two brakes failing on their own at the same time would be unlikely1. The owner of a seven year old VW motorhome nearly burned his fingers on both rear rims after a holiday drive, having heard only an occasional squeal from the back2. With a parking brake drum inside the disc the heat sits at the centre of the wheel: on a van of the Sprinter and LT family, water splashed between the hub and the disc boiled after 20 km while the rim itself was only hand warm5. The heat can be mistaken for something else, and the owner of a 2003 Sprinter motorhome whose rear wheels smelled of rubber in summer heat first suspected the wheel bearings, until he found the parking brake shoes rubbing hard against the drums6.

A single hot rear wheel narrows it down less than it seems. It can be that wheel's own cylinder, shoes or adjuster, but it can just as well be the cable to that wheel: on one pickup, slush had frozen the parking brake cable on one side only7. Even the equalizer can favour one side. On the Sprinter with both rears hot, it rocked on its spring so that first one wheel cable and then the other had no play at all1.

The hand lever often gives the fault away, because a mechanism that does not return also changes how the lever feels. A Sprinter owner and the owner of the VW motorhome both noticed that the lever had to be pulled much higher than before until the brake held, at the same time as the rear brakes started to drag8,2. When the lever on the equalizer sticks in the applied position, the brake stays on after release while the front cable from the hand lever goes slack, so the hand lever lifts with almost no resistance9,10. A VW LT 28 owner describes the same as free travel over the first teeth of the lever8. On the Sprinter and LT van with the boiling hubs, the front cable sagged a good 10 cm after release because the equalizer had not gone all the way back5.

Noise and a loss of performance are the other common reports. A Ford Falcon owner could hear the shoes rubbing although his parking brake otherwise worked11, and on a 1990 BMW 325i both rear parking brakes were rubbing badly, so that the car felt quicker once they had been adjusted, although a grinding noise from the rear left came back later and the owner again suspected the parking brake12. On a Mia electric car the left rear drum first made a loud rubbing noise only when pulling away in winter, then during the whole drive, and became very hot after a few kilometres13. On the Sprinter whose star wheels were set too tight, fuel use at 100 to 105 km/h dropped from about 14 to 13 litres per 100 km once they were backed off1.

Telling it apart from other causes

Before working under the car, secure it: chock the front wheels, put the gearbox in neutral, raise the rear and support it on axle stands, and only then release the parking brake1. Turning each rear wheel by hand then shows which ones drag, and it is best done with both sides lifted so that they can be compared1,14. On the Sprinter with both rears hot, both wheels scraped from the inside, and the owner put it down to the parking brake1.

Next find out whether the parking brake side is involved, because it is the easiest part to reach. If both rear wheels are hot, the cable equalizer near the middle of the underbody is the first thing to look at9. Have someone pull and release the hand lever while you watch it: after release it should spring back by itself, the front cable should stay taut, and the two wheel cables should each keep a little play. Check the return spring of the equalizer too, for broken or tired coils1. If loosening the adjusting nut at the equalizer until both wheel cables have play frees the wheels, the parking brake was holding them1,9. The Sprinter owner with the rocking equalizer loosened it until each wheel cable had about 5 mm of play, as a stopgap to get home, and his brakes ran much cooler on the way1.

If the wheel cables have play and a wheel still drags, back the shoes off at the wheel. On the Sprinter the star wheel of the adjuster can be reached with a screwdriver through an empty wheel bolt hole, turned to about nine o'clock on the driver's side and three o'clock on the passenger's side, and it clicks once per tooth1. On the older Sprinter with twin rear tyres, built until 2006, it is reached through a separate hole in the disc from above15. A parking brake that already holds fully after one or two clicks of the hand lever is set too tight1. In the same thread one owner advised that if the wheel still does not turn more easily after the shoes have been backed off, the problem lies with the service brake rather than the parking brake1. On a van with discs at the rear that means the caliper, through seized slide pins, a stuck piston or seal or pads stuck in the carrier, which is what another poster in that thread found on his own van after the parking brake1.

On a full drum brake the service brake is the wheel cylinder and the shoes, and the wheel cylinder has a bleed screw of its own. While the brake is dragging, open it. If the wheel frees as soon as the screw is open, the brake was being held by pressure from further up the line, not by anything at the wheel. If the wheel still drags with the screw open, the fault is at the wheel itself: the cylinder, the shoes, the adjuster or the parking brake. How much fluid comes out does not decide it; whether the wheel frees does. Close the screw at once, top up the reservoir and bleed that brake before the car moves. The test only works while the brake is dragging.

With the drum off, look at the cylinder: black crud on it means its seal has begun to leak16, and so does fluid behind its rubber boots. To see whether the pistons move, have a helper press the pedal very gently while you watch the shoes: both should move out a little and be pulled fully back by the springs when the pedal is released. Press only lightly and only a little, because without the drum to stop them the pistons can be pushed right out of the cylinder. Look at the return springs as well: on a 2001 Jeep Cherokee whose rear brakes locked up too easily, which is a related fault rather than drag, a reply pointed out that tired springs and stiff linkage let the shoes apply too readily and that the springs cost little to replace16.

If the bleed screw test shows pressure held from further up, or the front brakes are hot as well, look along the line from the pedal to the wheel: the pedal and brake light switch, the booster and pushrod, the master cylinder, the ABS unit where fitted, the rear pressure regulator or proportioning valve, and the flexible hose. Whether the ABS unit or the regulator comes first varies by car. A single hose on a rigid rear axle feeds both rear brakes, so a fault there can heat both rears just like a parking brake fault.

A brake that has frozen or rusted to its drum while the vehicle stood is a related but different problem: the car refuses to move at first and is usually fine once it is free. A 1991 Chrysler Fifth Avenue would barely back up after standing in wet weather, and the mechanic found both rear wheel cylinders leaking badly. A reply offered two explanations: cast iron cylinders rust as they start to leak and may lock the pistons, leaving a shoe dragging, and fluid that has leaked onto the linings can rust them to the drum if the parking brake is left on, which it suggested was why the car would not back up17. A Sprinter that had stood for five months would turn its rear wheels only a short distance before they locked as if against a stop. The owner freed it with two or three light taps on the parking brake shoes through a hole in the disc18. On a 2005 Ford Ranger that would not move after eight salty winters, penetrating oil, hammers and a hair dryer freed the rear brakes enough to drive it to a mechanic19.

Repairing it

Do one side at a time, so that the untouched side shows how the springs and the adjuster go back together, since some parts, such as the adjusters, differ between left and right19,20. Before pulling a drum, back the shoes off and take the tension off the parking brake cable, otherwise the drum catches on the shoes. On a self-adjusting drum the pawl of the automatic adjuster stops the star wheel from turning back, so it has to be held away with a second screwdriver through the access hole while the first one turns the wheel21. A Sienna owner who beat his combined disc and drum off with a sledgehammer without backing the shoes off had to buy new shoes and hardware4, and a Sprinter owner who forgot the same nearly ruined a wheel bearing22. On a first generation Honda Fit a reply advised releasing the cable tension under the console and then screwing two bolts of 8 or 10 mm into the threaded holes in the drum to push it off; the 4WD version has no such holes, and there a slide hammer got the drum off23. On a Scion xB, M8 x 1.25 bolts in those holes freed a drum that had not moved at all20. A rust ridge worn into the drum can stop it from sliding over the shoes, and hammering it can crack the drum, damage the friction surface or the wheel bearing, so a puller is the gentler tool: its jaws grip the drum while its centre screw pushes against the hub, and a few taps on the jaws help it along4. If you do use a hammer, give several measured blows all round the drum instead of hitting one spot14. When nothing else worked, Sprinter owners cut the combined disc and drum off. One advised cutting about three quarters through with an angle grinder and splitting the rest with a firm hammer blow6; another cut a full radial slot with the grinder and a saw and drove a screwdriver in as a wedge24. Both took care not to cut into the parts inside, and the disc is scrap afterwards.

A stuck equalizer or lever can be freed with penetrating oil and by working it back and forth, but in owners' reports that did not last. One Sprinter owner's fix held only a few days, a Mercedes workshop's freeing held about three weeks, and only renewing the bearing points of the intermediate shaft cured it for good9. Owners who removed the equalizer, cleaned off the rust and dirt and refitted it well greased report that it worked again15,3,25. On one Sprinter the thick front pivot bolt was so seized that a hammer would not move it, and it turned again only after half an hour in penetrating oil and a coat of molybdenum spray10. A greasing job is no guarantee, though: after a dealer took one equalizer apart and greased it, the brake still stuck and one rim still ran warm9. Where the parking brake lock had rusted solid and could not be freed, it was replaced8.

For a parking brake cable that sticks in its sheath, opinions differ. One poster, a mechanic, cuts rusted cables and replaces them during the brake job, and another has never managed to free a binding cable26. A third poster has freed cables by taking them off and bending them a few dozen times, then soaking them overnight in oil, which works only sometimes, and a set of sticky cables soaked in drain oil lasted about six months before new ones were needed26. The most thorough method in that thread is to take the cable off, bend it until it moves, then pull it as far out of the sheath as it goes and grease it, not oil it, with the sheath hanging down, repeating until it slides freely. Its author has never had to do the same cable twice, though the cars he did it on lasted no more than three years, and he stresses that the brake then has to be used to keep it free26. On a Mia forum another owner freed a rusted rear cable by hanging it up and pouring oil in until it ran out at the bottom13, and on a Sprinter the front cable was greased from the hand lever end, under the lever's cover1. A cable that has frozen with slush releases once it thaws7, so in frost the advice is to warm the cables, for example with a hair dryer, instead of hammering9,19. The cable is also not always the culprit: on a Ford truck the release mechanism in the cab had rusted, and cleaning and oiling it fixed the sticking26,27.

Leaking or seized wheel cylinders are replaced. On the Mia the workshop found a seized wheel cylinder on both rear wheels as well as the seized parking brake cable13. On the Chrysler the mechanic replaced both rear cylinders and the car then drove without problems, and a reply hoped he had also replaced the shoes, which leaked fluid had reached, and checked the drums17. On the Jeep the drums turned out to hold leaking cylinders on both sides, a lot of crud and paper thin shoes. The owner fitted new cylinders, shoes and the hardware kit with its springs, cleaned a ledge of rust off the drums with a file and bled the brakes, and the pedal was firm and the brakes solid afterwards16. A wheel cylinder job opens the hydraulic system, so it always ends with bleeding the brakes until the fluid comes out free of air, and checking for a firm pedal before driving. Shoes that have dragged for long can be finished too: on a VW LT2 they had heat cracks after being driven with the parking brake on25, and a Sprinter poster warned that dragging parking brake shoes can wear a ridge into the drum14.

The order of adjustment matters. Set the shoes at the wheel first, with the cable slack, and only then take up the cable11,16,1. For the Sprinter, a poster gives the procedure from the Mercedes workshop manual. Remove one wheel bolt on each rear wheel, raise the rear, and loosen the lock nut and adjusting nut at the equalizer so that the cables are slack. Turn the star wheel through the bolt hole until the wheel can no longer be turned, then back it off three to four teeth until the wheel turns freely, and repeat on the other side. Then pull and release the hand lever several times, pull it to the third notch, and tighten the adjusting nut until the rear wheels can only just still be turned by hand. Work the lever a few more times, check that the wheels turn freely with it released, tighten the lock nut and refit the wheel bolts to their torque1. Another owner's write-up backs the star wheel off by the same three to four teeth28,15. The Sprinter owner with both rears hot found his star wheels only two clicks from locking the wheel, backed them off eight clicks until the scraping stopped and then set the equalizer so that the wheel cables just kept some play; the lever now travels further but holds on a slope1. While the drum is off, clean the teeth of the adjuster and lubricate its thread. Owners disagree about what with. One recommends copper paste or a grease that stands the heat6. On the Jeep, one poster advised silicone grease on the adjuster threads and said anti-seize belongs only on the backing plate ledges, another has used anti-seize on adjuster threads for 30 years without trouble, and a third holds that anti-seize has no place anywhere in a drum brake because it is not a lubricant for moving parts16. The shoes rest on raised ledges on the backing plate, and these should be cleaned and greased so that the shoes slide on them; the first of those posters suggested white lithium grease16. On a Ford Falcon wagon that kept rubbing, the owner chamfered the edge of the shoe lining, bent a new retaining clip to hold the shoe firmly against the backing plate, greased the three contact points, cleaned the drum and set the parking brake to be fully on at four clicks, after many failed attempts11. Simply backing the parking brake off is no cure, since on a Falcon BA that stopped the noise but left a parking brake that no longer held11. Finally, drive a short distance, then check that all wheels turn freely and that the rear wheels are no warmer than the fronts.

What owners did

CarWhat was wrongWhat was doneResult
Mercedes-Benz Sprinter, rearEqualizer lever seized again and againFreed with penetrating oil, then by a Mercedes workshop, finally bearing points of the intermediate shaft renewedFirst two lasted days and weeks, the last worked faultlessly9
Mercedes-Benz Sprinter, both rearsStar wheels two clicks from locking, equalizer rocking so one cable had no playStar wheels backed off eight clicks, equalizer reset with play on both cablesScraping gone, cooler brakes, about 1 l/100 km less fuel1
Sprinter or LT van, both rearsEqualizer not returning, front cable sagging about 10 cmCleaned with brake cleaner and penetrating oil, greased, worked several timesNo problems in 4,000 km5
VW motorhome, both rearsEqualizer seized, drum shoes worn out, right disc ruinedVW workshop replaced the equalizer, the drum shoes and both discs with padsRepaired for 711 EUR at 70,000 km2
Mercedes-Benz Sprinter 316 CDI 2003, rearParking brake shoes dragging hard, discs rusted onDiscs cut with an angle grinder and splitDiscs off; setting the shoes was laborious6
Mia, both rearsLeft rear rubbing and very hotWorkshop found both rear wheel cylinders and the parking brake cable seizedNot reported13
Chrysler Fifth Avenue 1991, rearBoth wheel cylinders leaking badly, car held back in reverseMechanic replaced both wheel cylindersDrove without problems17
Ford Falcon BF wagon, rearParking brake shoes rubbing and draggingShoe edges chamfered, retaining clip renewed, contact points greased, drum cleaned, adjusted at the wheelNo noise for six months, wheel turns easily11

Keeping it from coming back

Parking brakes seize when they are not used, so the simplest prevention is to use the parking brake regularly26. A workshop mechanic advised a Sprinter owner to pull the lever lightly now and then while rolling slowly, so that the shoes wipe rust and dirt out of the drum8. Do this only at walking pace on a clear, dry road with nothing behind you, never at speed or on a slippery surface, where a rear wheel can lock. The equalizer under the car is exposed to spray, salt and dirt, and owners who have had it seize keep it lubricated: one owner crawls under his van to oil it every four months at the latest and would rather do it every second month2, a Sprinter owner advises regular greasing with too much rather than too little15, and a fleet owner with about ten vans covers the whole lever with a thick gear grease and has had no seizing since, while ordinary rust removers lasted him a month at most10. On a VW LT 28 used at the beach, blown sand seized the equalizer three times, and its owner now cleans and greases it regularly8. Clean before greasing, since on one Sprinter old grease had turned into a hard lump of dirt that itself stopped the mechanism15. Some owners fit a home made plastic cover over the equalizer to keep spray and dirt off10.

For a vehicle that will stand for months, owners advise wheel chocks and a gear engaged instead of the parking brake, because shoes left applied can rust to the drum18. One VW LT buyer had to cut a cable to get home because the seller had left the parking brake on and it had stuck in the drum5. Chocks alone do not prevent seizing, though: the Sprinter that would not move after five months had stood with its parking brake off18, and the parts seized all the same. A reply on the Ford Ranger advised driving it on the road every day once the brakes were free19. On steep ground chocks alone may not feel safe, as a Mia owner in hilly country pointed out13, and there the parking brake stays on with the chocks added. When a drum is refitted, a thin coat of graphite grease on the hub keeps it from rusting on, as one owner found when he took it off again five years later21.

Where it comes up most

The Mercedes Sprinter and the VW LT of the second generation come up again and again in owners' reports. They share the same rear brakes with a drum parking brake inside the disc3, and their parking brake equalizer under the floor is known among owners as an old weak point that rusts solid2,15, on vans used every day as well as on motorhomes that stand for long periods9,10,5,25. It has seized as early as 70,000 km2, and on one 1998 LT2 it worked for 22 years without service before it did25. One owner of an older Toyota pickup found that its parking brake kept sticking whatever he cleaned or replaced27.

Further reading

Sources

  1. Bremsen Hinterräder heiß, sprinter-forum.de
  2. Quietschen hinten, sprinter-forum.de
  3. welches Bremssystem hat mein LT2?, sprinter-forum.de
  4. Rear rotor stuck on 2008 Tribeca, community.cartalk.com
  5. Hinterräder SAUheiß - morgen Urlaubsantritt!!, sprinter-forum.de
  6. Hintere Radlager heiß, sprinter-forum.de
  7. Rear wheel jammed, community.cartalk.com
  8. Sprinter Bremssattel Probleme, sprinter-forum.de
  9. Problem: Handbremse fest, sprinter-forum.de
  10. Handbremse, sprinter-forum.de
  11. Help BA Falcon HandBrake | Ford Forums, fordforums.com
  12. '90 325i Project Log… continued, r3vlimited.com
  13. Ähnliche Themen, goingelectric.de
  14. Frage zur Überhitzung der Bremsen nach Austausch hinten – Sprinter 906 (Wohnmobil), sprinter-forum.de
  15. Handbremse..., sprinter-forum.de
  16. 2001 Jeep Cherokee Brakes, community.cartalk.com
  17. 1991 Chrysler front end shaking -- update?, community.cartalk.com
  18. Motor läuft Sprinter fährt aber nicht, sprinter-forum.de
  19. Ford Ranger will not move (parking brake stuck on?), community.cartalk.com
  20. rear drums stuck | Scion xB Forum, clubxb.com
  21. Проблемы со снятием тормозного барабана, geely-club.com
  22. Gerissener Handbremszug, sprinter-forum.de
  23. Народ подскажите как снять задний барабан?? Он кажется прикипел и всё. Просто выбивать насильно? Или есть нюансы? Фит 4wd 1, honda-com.ru
  24. Bremsscheibenausbau brutal!, sprinter-forum.de
  25. Neuer mit VW LT2 2,3B LT35 Bus, sprinter-forum.de
  26. Best way to free up sticking parking brake cables?, community.cartalk.com
  27. Emergency hand brake stuck, community.cartalk.com
  28. Handbremse einstellen, sprinter-forum.de