Cars and vans › Brakes › Brake drag › Causes

Hose holding pressure

A cause of brake drag on hydraulic brakes, at the wheel or axle the failed hose feeds.

Between the rigid steel lines on the body and the brakes sit short flexible brake hoses, which let the wheels steer and the suspension move. Inside their reinforced outer layers is a thin rubber liner that carries the brake fluid. When you brake, the master cylinder pushes fluid through the hose into the caliper, or into the wheel cylinder of a drum brake, and when you lift your foot that small amount of fluid has to flow back the same way so the piston can retract. As a hose ages, the liner can fail inside it while the hose still looks perfect from the outside1,2.

Owners and mechanics describe three ways this happens. The liner can collapse inward1,3, it can swell until the bore is nearly closed, which German Sprinter owners describe as a hose that has grown shut4,5, or a piece of it can come loose and hang inside like a flap6,7,8,9. Any of these can work like a check valve. The pedal forces fluid past the obstruction with far more pressure than anything that pushes it back, because on release only the piston seal and the slight springiness of the caliper and pads drive the fluid home. The pressure stays trapped behind the piston and the pads keep pressing on the disc6,10,11. Depending on how tight the restriction is, the brake either lets go slowly, which wears the pads out early12, or stays on until the pressure is let out; one owner said that in a bad case the wheels lock up13.

The fault is easy to miss for that reason: the hose gives no outward sign, and in several of these threads calipers, pads and discs were replaced before anyone looked at the hose6,14.

How it shows up

Each front wheel has its own hose, so a failed front hose makes one front wheel drag, the same way a seized caliper does: that wheel runs hot, its brake smells, and the car pulls toward it. A 1988 Oldsmobile Ciera started pulling to the left, and its left front hub was very hot after parking1. A 1999 Ford Escort ZX2 pulled to the left at a traffic light, then drove as if the brakes were on and smelled of burning rubber, and the shop found the rubber hose rather than the caliper at fault9. On a rigid rear axle, such as on many vans and pickups, a single hose usually feeds both rear brakes, which is why one F-350 owner was asked about his three brake hoses2; a failed hose there makes both rears drag. Both front hoses can also fail together: a reply on a Corolla with both front calipers hot said the fix on his own car had been to replace both front hoses13.

A long history of brake jobs that do not last points upstream of the caliper, to the hose or to anything else that can hold pressure, rather than to the caliper itself. Pads and discs on that wheel wear out within months, and new calipers do not help. On a 1995 Chevrolet Blazer two sets of front pads and calipers lasted about three months each12, a 2002 Ford F-150 had its calipers, discs and pads replaced twice and still smelled of hot brakes, with smoke coming off the discs on a steep descent10, and a 1994 Acura Legend locked its right rear brake again after new calipers had been fitted15. In all three a reply suggested the hoses, but none of the owners reported the outcome. A mechanic on a Volvo thread described a car whose pads, discs and calipers had been replaced at a shop that missed a collapsed hose: a few months and about 3,000 miles later it was back with the pads on that corner worn to the backing plate and the disc ground below its minimum thickness14. A Sprinter forum member had the same experience on an older Mercedes, where new calipers were fitted before swollen hoses turned out to be the cause4. The same history fits the other upstream causes, though: on a Sprinter 313 CDI a new caliper and then a new hose both left the rear right brake hanging11.

Telling it apart from other causes

Start by finding out whether the brake is held by pressure at all. The test only works while the brake is dragging. Lift the wheel, confirm it is hard to turn, and open the bleed screw on that caliper with a clear hose on it leading into a jar. If the wheel frees as soon as the screw is open, the brake was being held by pressure from further up8,7; if it still drags with the screw open, the fault is at the wheel itself, and a stuck piston or seal, seized slide pins or pads stuck in the carrier are the candidates. How much fluid comes out does not decide it; whether the wheel frees does. One reply on a Civic suggested pumping the pedal several times just before opening the screw6. A bleed screw that has not been opened for years can snap, as one did on the Corolla, whose owner then planned to soak and tap the others for days before trying them13. Close the screw at once, top up the reservoir and bleed that brake before the car moves.

A wheel that frees at the bleed screw tells you only that pressure is held somewhere upstream, and the hose is one of several places. From the pedal to the wheel the fluid's path runs through the pedal and brake light switch, the booster and its pushrod and the master cylinder, then the ABS unit where one is fitted and, for the rear brakes, a pressure regulator or proportioning valve, and only then the flexible hose and the caliper or wheel cylinder. Whether the ABS unit or the regulator comes first varies by car. On a 2002 Honda Civic both front bleed screws squirted, and the owner replaced both hoses, then the calipers, pads and discs, and the brakes still dragged; the cause was a brake light switch refitted so that it kept the pedal from coming fully up6. On a Sprinter 311 CDI whose rear right brake stuck even after new hoses, the culprit was the brake regulator valve at the rear axle, which let pressure through to the brake but released it only very slowly or not at all16.

To find where the pressure is held, open the joints one at a time, from the wheel upwards. The first joint above the caliper is where the steel line meets the hose. The brake has to be dragging again before each step, because every opened joint lets the pressure go. A wheel that frees at once when a joint is opened clears everything between that joint and the wheel, so if the brake frees at once at the steel line to hose joint, the hose is cleared; if it frees only at the bleed screw, the hose is holding it. A part that lets pressure back only slowly can still let the brake go a while after a joint further up is opened, so a wheel that frees slowly clears nothing. The Sprinter 311 CDI shows why: its brake freed when the owner opened its line at the ABS unit, and he concluded a valve in the ABS unit was sticking, yet the slow regulator below it turned out to be the cause16. Releasing pressure at the regulator's inlet therefore does not clear a regulator that lets pressure back slowly, and no owner describes a test that tells such a regulator apart from a sticking valve in the ABS unit.

A Sprinter 312 D owner worked through a rear brake that would not let go in this order, pressing the pedal to lock the brake again before each step. The brake released when he loosened the line at the regulator's outlet, which he took as ruling out a swollen hose, and again at the regulator's inlet, which he took as clearing the regulator and leaving the ABS unit as the next part in line. A full stop with the ABS working freed the brake, but it was stuck again after 10 km11. A reply on a 1994 Chevrolet Silverado took the same idea to the top of the line: the next time the brakes lock, crack the line from the master cylinder to the front brakes and see whether they release; then, with the brakes dragging again, undo the master cylinder's mounting nuts so it can move forward, and if that releases them, suspect the brake booster, its pushrod adjustment or the pedal linkage7. Tighten each joint straight away, cover the paintwork against fluid, and bleed the brakes afterwards, using the scan tool routine on ABS cars that need one.

On a 1995 Chevrolet Blazer a reply described a test without opening anything. With the front raised and secured on stands, the transmission in neutral, the parking brake on and the wheels chocked, a helper applies and releases the brake with the engine off while you spin each front wheel. A wheel that does not free points to the hose or the master cylinder; if every wheel frees with the engine off but not with it running, suspect the booster. The poster stressed that nobody should be under or in front of the car while the engine runs with the wheels raised12.

Which wheels drag narrows the search before any of this. A front hose feeds one wheel and a single hose on a rigid rear axle feeds both rears, while a diagonally split master cylinder circuit feeds one front wheel and the opposite rear6, and a fault at the pedal, pushrod or booster holds both circuits. A reply in the Volvo thread pointed out that crud blocking a return port in the master cylinder would make two diagonal brakes stick, whereas a collapsed hose sticks only its own caliper14. Two front hoses failing together is possible, as the Corolla reply shows13, though one mechanic thought it likely only if the fluid had been contaminated at some point6. Both fronts dragging together therefore points to the master cylinder side or to both front hoses, and the tests above tell them apart.

Uneven wear between the two pads of one caliper points elsewhere first, since trapped pressure presses both pads. A 2013 Ford Expedition wore its outer pad to metal in 3,600 miles, and a reply suggested sticking calipers or collapsed hoses, but the inner and outer pads had been fitted in each other's places; with them refitted correctly the brake worked properly17.

Repairing it

A brake that is held on overheats, and a reply on a 2003 Passat pointed out that a dragging caliper can boil its fluid18, so the car should not be driven until the cause is repaired. Opening the bleed screw releases the brake only until the pedal is pressed again: on the Silverado the brakes locked again at the next application7.

A failed hose cannot be repaired, only replaced, and since a hose cannot be inspected from the outside, the usual advice is to replace the hoses in pairs or all at once. A Sprinter owner recommended changing all four, as they cost little and give years of peace4, and on old cars replies recommend new hoses before parts further up are replaced: on the 1995 Blazer because the truck had reached an age where hoses break down inside12, and on the 2002 F-150 at the next brake job10. A new hose corrected the pull and the hot hub on the Ciera, and new hoses fixed the same fault on a 2008 Mustang1. The Volvo 850 is less clear. Its shop found the front hoses dripping too slowly and replaced all four with the fluid, yet 700 miles later the same front caliper ran hot again, and it was hot again after a rebuilt caliper was fitted. Only at the end of the thread, after a different shop had rebalanced the wheels and the vibration had changed, did the owner conclude that the hoses had cured the original seizure14.

Look at the parts the hose has been working against. The constant heat ruins pads and discs, which on the car the mechanic described were far past saving14, and a reply on the F-150 warned that it warps discs10. While the caliper is loose, support it on the suspension with wire or a hook rather than letting it hang by a hose. When fitting the new hose, make sure it is not twisted, which happens when a caliper has been off and is refitted carelessly, and that any steel bracket wrapped around it is not rusted tight enough to squeeze it, since both restrict the hose in the same way6. Replacing a hose lets air into that circuit, so finish by bleeding the brake, or the whole system if the reservoir ran low, and pump the pedal until it is firm before the car moves.

What owners did

CarWhat was wrongWhat was doneResult
Oldsmobile Ciera 1988, front leftCar pulled left, hub very hot, brake not releasingNew hoseCorrected1
Ford Mustang 2008Brake not releasing, same as the CieraNew brake hosesFixed1
Ford Escort ZX2 1999, frontPulled left, drove as if braked, burning smellShop found the rubber hose, not the caliper, and quoted two hoses with front discs and rear brake workOutcome after the repair not posted9
Toyota Corolla, both fronts (a reply's own car)Front brakes draggingBoth front hoses replacedFixed, per the reply13
Volvo 850 1995, front leftCaliper hot, steering shake, black dust; front hoses dripped too slowly when disconnectedAll four hoses and the fluid, later a rebuilt caliperHot again twice afterwards; owner finally credited the hoses, with a later vibration traced to wheel balance14
Unnamed car in a shopOne corner worn to the backing plate within about 3,000 milesEarlier shop replaced pads, discs and calipers and lubed the slidersFault returned; a collapsed hose was found on its return14
Honda Civic 2002, both fronts (not the hose)Fluid squirted from both front bleed screwsBoth hoses, then calipers, pads, discs and fluid replacedStill dragged; a misplaced brake light switch held the pedal down6
Mercedes Sprinter 313 CDI 2001, rear right (not the hose)Brake hangs after hard pumping, pressure at the bleed screwNew caliper, then a new hose, line blown throughNo change; ABS unit suspected11

Keeping it from coming back

Hoses deteriorate with age, so when calipers or pads are being done on an older car, replies suggest replacing the flexible hoses at the same time rather than leaving the old ones in13,14. A hose can also be damaged inside during brake work, when a caliper is left hanging by it instead of being supported1, so whenever a caliper comes off, hang it from the suspension and refit the hose without a twist6. Keep the fluid itself in good condition: the mechanic who doubted that two hoses would fail at once made an exception for fluid that had been contaminated, and asked whether the system had ever been flushed6.

Further reading

Sources

  1. "Underdesigned" Brakes Likely Causing Problem (Newspaper Column), community.cartalk.com
  2. Brakes lock up when i gently tap the brake pedal. | Ford Forums, fordforums.com
  3. Brake problems | Page 2 | Ford Forums, fordforums.com
  4. bremsattel 312d, sprinter-forum.de
  5. Anfrage Bremsenreperatur, sprinter-forum.de
  6. Sticking Front Brakes, community.cartalk.com
  7. Brake problem, community.cartalk.com
  8. Brakes stuck, community.cartalk.com
  9. 1999 ford escort zx2, community.cartalk.com
  10. Reoccuring rotor/caliper issue, community.cartalk.com
  11. Bremse hängt, Druck in der Leitung geht nicht weg..., sprinter-forum.de
  12. 1995 Chevy Blazer 4wd front brakes/control arm, community.cartalk.com
  13. '97 Corolla brakes dragging...bleed 'em?, community.cartalk.com
  14. Brake Caliper Question, community.cartalk.com
  15. Brake Caliper still sticking | Acura Legend Forum, acura-legend.com
  16. Betriebsbremse hängt fest, sprinter-forum.de
  17. Is this a bad brake caliper? | Ford Forums, fordforums.com
  18. Brakes fail after 30 minutes, community.cartalk.com