Cars and vans › Brakes › Brake drag › Causes

Caliper piston or seal stuck

A cause of brake drag on disc brakes, floating and fixed calipers alike.

A disc brake caliper presses its pads against the disc with one or more pistons, each sliding in a bore filled with brake fluid. Around each piston sits a rubber ring, the piston seal, which keeps the fluid in and also pulls the piston back. When you brake, the piston moves out and drags the seal with it so that the seal twists slightly in its groove; when the pressure drops, the seal springs back to its resting shape and draws the piston with it, which leaves the pad just clear of the disc1. A rubber dust boot over the open end of the piston keeps water and dirt away from the polished surface the seal runs on. If that surface rusts, if dirt and corrosion build up between piston and bore, or if the seal has gone hard and lost its spring, the piston no longer comes back. It stays out and holds its pad against the disc although there is no pressure left in the line2,3.

The reasons owners and mechanics give come down to water and age. Water gets in where the boot is missing or damaged: on a London taxi whose pistons have only a wiper ring instead of a proper dust boot, the pistons keep rusting tight4, and one Twizy owner describes the unprotected front piston slowly pitting until it seizes, so that the pads barely move back after braking5. Brake fluid itself takes up water from the air over the years, and old fluid is suspected of corroding pistons and bores and wearing out the seals: when a 2009 Nissan Rogue needed new front calipers at about 82,000 km and a rear one at 104,000 km, the replies suspected fluid that had been left unchanged under the previous owner3. A worn seal is enough on its own, as on a Sprinter 412D motorhome that loses a caliper almost every year because a seal worth a few cents starts leaking at a piston4. Owners link the fault to vehicles that are driven little, whose brakes seldom get warm enough to drive off moisture that has got in: the London taxi is used only now and then, and a Sprinter poster has seen pistons stop releasing on vehicles that were driven little4,6.

How it shows up

A stuck piston gives the same signs as any brake that stays on at one wheel: heat, a burning smell, a pull and sometimes a vibration. In the clearest reports the piston itself was found stuck. On a Mercedes W201 a seized rear left piston made an ugly noise from the rear axle while first the pad and then its steel backing plate rubbed on the disc7. On a Mia electric car the front brakes got hot on almost every trip and the car lost performance, because the pistons had seized8. The owner of a Honda Accord with a K24 engine smelled burning linings when he arrived at work; the rear left disc had turned purple, the pads were at their limit with the piston standing far out of its bore, and the workshop fitted a new piston and seals in that caliper9.

Other reports only say that a caliper was stuck or seized, without finding out whether the piston, the slides or something upstream was to blame. A 2005 Dodge Dakota pulled hard to the left and coasted badly for a week before the pads smoked, and the shop called it a sticking left caliper10. On a 1975 Ford pickup a seized caliper heated the rim almost red within half a mile; its owner thinks the worn-out pad caused the seizure11. On a 1995 Civic one front wheel wore its pads to the wear indicator while the other side had about twice as much left; the owner suspected the piston, but a replier asked whether the slides were binding instead, and the thread ends without an answer12. Cases like these show what a stuck caliper feels like, and the next section shows how to find out whether the piston is the reason.

The fault can also first show at a pad change, as a piston that will not go back. On a 1999 Mustang GT the left rear piston could not be wound back in, even with a tool rented for the job13. A Toyota 4Runner owner who replaced his rotors because the brakes pulsed found one of the four pistons in a caliper stuck and replaced that caliper too14. On rear calipers that also carry the parking brake, a seized caliper can stop the parking brake working on that wheel: on a 1993 Accord the cable was fine and the seized caliper was to blame15.

Telling it apart from other causes

First make sure which wheel is dragging, as described under Is it really dragging?. Then rule out pressure that is held further up the line. While the brake is dragging, open the bleed screw on that wheel. If the wheel frees as soon as the screw is open, the brake was being held by pressure from further up: from the master cylinder side, the ABS unit, for a rear brake the rear pressure regulator, or a hose acting as a one-way valve. If the wheel still drags with the screw open, the fault is at the wheel itself, in the caliper or its mounting16,17,13. How much fluid comes out does not decide it; whether the wheel frees does. Close the screw at once, top up the reservoir and bleed that brake before the car moves. The test only works while the brake is dragging. On a 2001 Mustang GT whose front calipers kept sticking, the calipers stayed stuck with the bleeder open, and the owner took that as pointing at the pistons18. On a 1999 Mustang GT both front wheels stayed hard to turn with the bleeder open, which a replier read as the calipers or their mounting, but that thread ends without a cause being found13. Bleed screws that have not been opened for years can be rusted solid and break off when forced, as one did on a 1997 Corolla; an owner in the salt belt finds them frozen by the time a car is three years old19,20.

A hot rear wheel on a vehicle whose parking brake is a small drum inside the rear disc, as on the Mercedes Sprinter, the VW LT of the same era and the Subaru Tribeca21,22,23, can also come from the parking brake shoes, which the bleed screw test does not release. That case is described under wheel cylinder, shoes or adjuster.

With pressure ruled out, separate the piston from the slide pins. Take the caliper off and push the piston back with a C-clamp: it should go back smoothly with only modest force1. On a caliper with several pistons, check each one, since only one of four was stuck on the 4Runner14. Then slide a floating caliper on its pins by hand, as described under seized slide pins. Pad wear helps only partly. On a floating caliper the outer pad is pulled in by the caliper body sliding on its pins, so an outer pad or outer disc face that wears or overheats on its own points at the pins24. A worn inner pad fits both causes, because seized pins can also leave the inner pad doing all the work, as on the Jaguar XF under seized slide pins. The inner pad can wear down unnoticed: one Crafter and Sprinter owner points out that the wear sensor on these vans sits on the outer pad25. The two faults can also occur together, so a piston that is hard to push back is no reason to skip the pins.

Replacing the caliper on suspicion is an expensive way to test. On a Chevrolet Captiva one wheel ran above 100 °C, and new pads, a new brake cylinder and then a complete new caliper did not help; only new brake hoses on all wheels and fresh fluid did26. A 1999 Mercury Villager that locked a front brake after the ABS had worked got a new caliper, pads and hose without any change27, and a 1998 4Runner's front brake still locked on after new calipers and a new hose; its fault never showed on flat ground, so it was hard to catch in the act28. The bleed screw test above is the cheapest way to tell held pressure from a fault at the wheel, but only if it can be done while the brake drags.

Repairing it

A brake that stays on overheats, fades and boils the water the fluid has absorbed, so the car should not be driven on until it is repaired2,29. Working a stuck piston in and out with a clamp can make it move again for a while, but the fault returns: a Fiat owner had to do it again every six months until he fitted a new caliper1. At best it lets the car be moved to where the repair is done.

The lasting repair is either a rebuilt caliper or a new one. To rebuild, remove the pads, unbolt the caliper from its carrier and let a helper press the brake pedal to push the pistons out6. A piston can leave its bore suddenly and with force, so keep fingers out of the caliper and put a block of wood or a folded rag in front of it. On a caliper with several pistons, clamp the pistons that move freely, so that the pressure pushes out the stuck one instead of them. Expect fluid to run out and the reservoir to drain once a piston is free. Then discard the old seals, check each piston closely for scoring, dirt and a film of rust, clean the bore, and press the piston back in carefully with a new seal, without tilting it6. Seal kits are sold for calipers; for the Sprinter 412D a poster names ATE 11.0441-6007.2 and advises not to skimp on brake cylinder paste during assembly4. A piston that is pitted is replaced: the K24 Accord got a new piston and seals on the rear left caliper and new seals only on the right, where piston and guides were fine, together with new discs, pads and DOT 4 fluid9. Pistons that are stuck fast can be hard to get out; on a Jaguar XJS the calipers were left to soak in WD-40 overnight before the stuck pistons were to be pressed out30. Penetrating oil is mineral oil, which makes brake rubber swell, so every trace of it has to be cleaned out before the new seals go in. With the caliper off the car, a bleed screw that is rusted in can be freed by clamping the caliper in a vise and heating it, which is how one owner in the salt belt gets them out without breaking them19. One replier's rule is simpler still: a caliper whose piston binds is replaced rather than freed16.

Owners also fit remanufactured calipers. A 2000 Blazer's rear calipers, which began sticking after a pad change at 80,000 miles, were replaced with remanufactured ones and gave no trouble for the next two years and 20,000 miles12. Quality varies, though: the 2001 Mustang GT owner went through five remanufactured front calipers that stayed stuck before two worked, although other posters doubted that so many could be faulty and suspected the installation18. Whether to do both sides is argued: a shop replaced both calipers on the Dakota to keep the braking even10, and one replier finds that when one caliper gets sticky the other is not far behind12.

Rear calipers with a built-in parking brake work differently. The parking brake mechanism moves the piston through a screw, so the piston is wound back in rather than pushed15,19. With an electric parking brake the motor on the caliper has to be released first. A Geely owner held the parking brake button while switching the engine off and then wound the piston in clockwise with a tool that presses and turns at once; on one side it turned hard and would not go fully home, and he finished with a wrench. The first reply said he had done everything right. A later one added that the piston should turn easily, that it cannot be damaged as long as it does not bind, and that it can also be retracted by putting 12 volts on the motor's connector; another owner was unsure whether a scanner's service mode is needed31. Look up the procedure for the car before forcing anything.

When pushing pistons back, some mechanics open the bleed screw so that old fluid goes out rather than back towards the ABS unit, while others have done thousands of pad changes without it19. Every job that opens the caliper ends with bleeding the brakes, which the reply describing the rebuild stresses as well6. Afterwards the wheel should turn freely by hand after several presses of the pedal, and after a drive without hard braking it should be no hotter than the wheel on the other side.

What owners did

CarWhat was wrongWhat was doneResult
Ford Mustang GT 1999, rear leftPiston seized, could not be wound back inCaliper replaced and bledThat wheel fine; the fronts then dragged, cause not found13
Mercedes W201 2.3, rear leftPiston seized, pad and then backing plate rubbingNew caliper, discs, pads and parking brake shoes at a workshopDrove home without trouble7
Honda Accord (K24), rear leftDisc purple, pads at the limit, piston far outNew piston and seals, seals on the right, new discs, pads and DOT 4Acceptable, pistons sit about a centimetre further in9
Toyota 4RunnerBrakes pulsing; one of four pistons found stuckNew rotors and one caliperBrakes like new14
Ford Mustang GT 2001, frontBoth calipers stuck with the bleeder open, pistons suspectedRemanufactured calipers, new hoses, full bleedWorked after five faulty calipers18
Jaguar XJS 1989, rearPistons stuck in the calipersCalipers soaked in WD-40, new seals ready for the rebuildNot reported30

Keeping it from coming back

Since water is what rusts pistons, the main protection is fresh fluid and intact boots. Repliers to the Rogue owner recommend changing the brake fluid every two to three years3, and the London taxi owner adds checking the boots and driving the car regularly, so that the brakes warm up and drive off moisture that has got in4. A torn boot is worth replacing as soon as it is seen, before water reaches the piston. One Twizy owner recommends blasting the calipers clean with a pressure washer every few weeks5. A Mia owner walks round the car after longer drives and feels the brake temperature, which catches a sticking piston before it ruins the discs8. In the Sprinter 412D thread, another owner with the same problem has had no seized caliper in five years since fitting ATE calipers and pads all round, ATE front discs and Mercedes rear discs4.

Further reading

Sources

  1. Brake Caliper Question, community.cartalk.com
  2. Dragging disk brakes, community.cartalk.com
  3. 2009 Nissan Rogue - Calipers Seizing After 100,000 Km?, community.cartalk.com
  4. Bremsprobleme an 412D Womo, sprinter-forum.de
  5. Ähnliche Themen, goingelectric.de
  6. Heftige Schleifgeräusche beim Bremsen, sprinter-forum.de
  7. Mein almandinroter 2.3er, w201-ev.de
  8. Ähnliche Themen, goingelectric.de
  9. Радост и тъга, forums.hondabg.com
  10. 05 Dakota Brake job, community.cartalk.com
  11. How necessary is rotor turning/re surfacing?, community.cartalk.com
  12. Sticky brake caliper, community.cartalk.com
  13. Brake problems | Ford Forums, fordforums.com
  14. Resurfacing Rotors--Brakes, community.cartalk.com
  15. 93 Honda Accord passenger e-Brake not working, community.cartalk.com
  16. Brakes stuck, community.cartalk.com
  17. My brakes are locking up, community.cartalk.com
  18. Brake problem, community.cartalk.com
  19. Brake Piston Question, community.cartalk.com
  20. '97 Corolla brakes dragging...bleed 'em?, community.cartalk.com
  21. Quietschen hinten, sprinter-forum.de
  22. welches Bremssystem hat mein LT2?, sprinter-forum.de
  23. Rear rotor stuck on 2008 Tribeca, community.cartalk.com
  24. Brake rotor problem. Strange vibration and discoloration, community.cartalk.com
  25. Bremsbelagsanzeige, sprinter-forum.de
  26. Большой расход топлива. Городской режим, пробок минимум. Манера езды спокойная. Скорость по городу 50-60 км/час. В чем причина? У кого какой, geely-monjaro-club.ru
  27. Brake seized 2 times in 2 months, community.cartalk.com
  28. '98 4Runner RF Break Locks and Won't Release, community.cartalk.com
  29. Honda Prelude only 1 out of 4 wheels braking, community.cartalk.com
  30. Logi sisse, forum.automoto.ee
  31. Можно ли крутить и вдавливать поршни задних суппортов?, geely-club.by