Cars and vans › Brakes › Brake drag › Causes
Master cylinder side not returning
A cause of brake drag on any car with hydraulic brakes, disc or drum.
When you press the pedal, a pushrod moves the piston in the master cylinder forward. Its first few millimetres of travel cover a small hole into the reservoir, called the compensating port, and only from that point on does the piston build pressure in the brake lines. When you let go, a spring pushes the piston back past the port, so the lines are open to the reservoir again: the pressure drops to nothing, and any fluid that expands as the brakes warm up simply flows back. If the piston cannot return all the way, the port stays covered and the fluid in the lines is trapped. The brakes then hold a little pressure, the heat from that light drag makes the trapped fluid expand, and the expansion presses the pads or shoes on harder still. Owners describe exactly this: brakes that stick on once the fluid has warmed up, because it has nowhere to go1, and that lock because the fluid does not go back into the master cylinder2. Wilwood's customer support put the same thing to an Opel GT owner: the piston only has to be pushed in about 1 mm to block the port that lets hot fluid expand back into the reservoir3.
The piston can be kept from returning in several ways. The pedal may not come all the way up, because something is in its way or its return spring is weak. Even with the pedal fully up, a pushrod between pedal, brake booster and master cylinder that is too long keeps the piston forward. The booster itself can hold its output rod forward when it sticks inside. Or the fault sits in the master cylinder: debris in the ports, a sticking piston, or rubber cups that have swollen from the wrong fluid.
Which wheels drag depends on where the fault is, because a modern master cylinder has two pistons, each feeding its own circuit. Some cars split the circuits front and rear, others diagonally, so that each circuit serves one front wheel and the opposite rear. A fault in front of the master cylinder, at the pedal, the pushrod or the booster, holds both pistons forward and can make every brake drag. A fault inside one circuit of the master cylinder affects only that circuit's wheels, which on a diagonal system is one front and the opposite rear, as a reply in the Civic thread explained4. Yet the Civic, whose pedal was being held down, dragged only at the front while its rear drums worked normally4. A likely reason, which none of the threads tests, is that drum shoes are held off by strong return springs, so a small trapped pressure shows at the discs first.
How it shows up
The drag builds with driving instead of being there from the start. A 1963 Galaxie with drums all round drove normally for 10 to 15 miles and then stuck on at the front and rear1. On a 2002 Civic both front brakes began dragging after about ten miles, and an infrared thermometer read about 640 °F on each front caliper4. A 1964 Falcon owner noticed play in the pedal when he set off and a pedal that grew firmer the longer he drove2. A 1991 Camry's brakes tightened with frequent braking in heavy traffic until the car stopped and smoked, and let go again after a few minutes parked; that thread ends without an answer5. A Windstar whose brakes applied themselves after a few miles on the highway, until there was no free play left in the pedal, fits the pattern too, but its ABS light had long been on and the brakes seemed to pulse, so its owner was heading for an ABS scan instead6.
Watch the brake lights). Where a switch at the pedal turns them on, lights that stay on with nobody pressing the pedal mean the pedal is not back at its stop, and a pedal off its stop can be the very thing holding the master cylinder piston in. The Civic's brake lights were on with nobody in the car4, and an Opel GT's stayed on whenever its pedal failed to return fully7. Older cars such as the 1964 Falcon use a pressure switch on the master cylinder instead, so there the lights coming on while parked show that pressure is still in the lines2.
The pedal itself can tell you something too. A pedal that comes back slowly, stops part way, or has to be pulled up by hand points at the pedal or booster. A 1963 Thunderbird's pedal was reluctant to return until its booster was cleaned8, and on an Opel GT the brakes only let go once the driver hooked a foot behind the pedal and pulled it home7. On a 2005 Lada the brakes grabbed hard, held the car for a second or two after the pedal was released on a hill, and freed for a while after the pedal was pressed firmly a couple of times with the engine running9.
Telling it apart from other causes
A car whose brakes drag should not be driven on the road, but these tests only work while the drag is there. Reproduce it in short, slow runs close to home, and stop after each one to feel or measure every wheel, so that you catch the drag as soon as a wheel runs hot instead of after it has cooked the brakes. Then lift the car and check which wheels are hard to turn.
Start at a dragging wheel by opening its bleed screw. If the wheel frees as soon as the screw is open, the brake was being held by pressure from further up: a hose, the rear pressure regulator, the ABS unit or the master cylinder side. That is how the Galaxie's front wheels freed1, and how the Civic owner got home each time, although his first try produced only a little squirt4. How much fluid comes out does not decide it; whether the wheel frees does. If the wheel still drags with the screw open, the fault is at the wheel itself. On a 1999 Mustang opening the bleeder did not help, and a reply concluded it had to be the caliper or its mounting, although the thread ends unresolved after the new caliper did the same10. In that case look at a stuck piston or seal or seized slide pins. Close the screw at once, top up the reservoir and bleed that brake before the car moves.
Between the pedal and the wheel the pressure passes, in line order, the pedal and brake light switch, the booster and pushrod, the master cylinder, the ABS unit where one is fitted, for the rear brakes a pressure regulator or proportioning valve, and the flexible hose to each wheel; whether the ABS unit or the regulator comes first varies by car. Which wheels drag narrows this down. A front hose feeds one wheel, and a single hose on a rigid rear axle feeds both rears. Both rears hot with the fronts cool points to the master cylinder's rear circuit on a front and rear split system, or to the rear pressure regulator. A front wheel together with the opposite rear fits a diagonally split master cylinder circuit just as well as it fits the ABS unit. A fault at the pedal, pushrod or booster holds both circuits. A reply in the Civic thread doubted that two hoses would go bad at the same moment4, and in a Corolla thread with both fronts dragging and the rear drums cool, one poster recalled a Datsun 510 with the same picture that a master cylinder fixed11.
To find where the pressure is held, open the joints one at a time from the wheel upwards, which was also the advice on the Mustang10. The brake has to be dragging again before each step, because every opened joint lets the pressure go. A wheel that frees at once when a joint is opened clears everything between that joint and the wheel. A part that lets pressure back only slowly can still let the brake go a while after a joint further up is opened, so a wheel that frees slowly clears nothing. At the master cylinder, crack the line to the dragging brakes. If they free at once, everything downstream is clear and the pressure is held at the master cylinder or in front of it. If they do not free, the pressure is held further down, in the ABS unit, the rear pressure regulator or a hose. Releasing pressure at the regulator's inlet does not clear a regulator that lets pressure back slowly, and no owner describes a test that tells such a regulator apart from a sticking valve in the ABS unit. Once the master cylinder line has freed the brakes, wait for the next episode of drag and loosen the nuts that hold the master cylinder to the booster so it can move forward a little. If the brakes release now, the master cylinder was being held in by the pushrod, the booster or the pedal linkage12,5. If they stay on with the master cylinder free, the fault is inside it. Tighten each joint straight away, and bleed the brakes afterwards, using the scan tool routine on ABS cars that need one.
A few more checks separate pedal and booster. Pull the pedal back towards you by hand: if the drag or the brake lights go off, the pedal was not reaching its stop7,13. Then take away the boost with the car standing. One suggestion is to disconnect the vacuum hose from the booster and see whether the brakes let go14; plug the hose while it is off, as a reply in the Lada thread did, since an open hose is a large vacuum leak into the engine9. Another is to work the pedal with the hose off: a pedal that still sticks without assistance needs cleaning and lubricating at its pivot or a new return spring15. The Lada owner made the same comparison by stopping the engine, and his brakes released almost at once with the engine off but much more slowly with it running9. The standard booster test, pumping the pedal with the engine off and feeling it drop when the engine starts, only proves that the booster assists, and a reply in that thread noted that it says nothing about a booster that releases too slowly9.
Finally look at the brake fluid in the reservoir. A 1994 Silverado with both fronts locked had cloudy fluid, and one reply suggested it had been mixed with a petroleum based fluid that swells the master cylinder cups until they keep the compensating port covered12. Another poster on the Lada forum had exactly that after topping up with power steering fluid by mistake: the rubber in the master cylinder swelled and did not return properly, and the wheels got very hot9.
Repairing it
The repair depends on which of the tests above released the brakes, and it pays to finish that diagnosis before buying parts. The Civic owner replaced both front calipers, pads, discs and hoses and flushed the fluid, and the brakes still stuck until he found the real fault at the pedal4.
When the pedal is held down, find what holds it. On the Civic the plug on the pedal that the brake light switch presses against was missing, and the switch, pushed in without regard to the pedal position, kept the pedal from retracting fully. He put a bolt with a nut in the hole, made sure the pedal was fully back, then fitted the switch, and the brakes worked properly on a 30 to 40 mile drive4. A brake light switch set too far in was also suggested for a 1990 F250 whose brakes locked14. The yellow Opel GT in one long build thread shows how far such a fault can lead. On a trip to Carlisle both rear wheels locked and ran red hot while the fronts stayed cool, and the owner first blamed the adjustable proportioning valve his rear disc brakes need, whose knob had worked loose; Wilwood's support replied that rears holding pressure like that point to a master cylinder that does not fully return, from the pedal or a pushrod that is too long3. Later he wrote that the Carlisle drag may have come from the pedal not returning, after he replicated it in his driveway with the pedal hitting his power steering unit7. Spacers he had fitted to raise the front end had pushed the unit into the pedal's path, and removing them, with some loosening and repositioning of its mounting bolts, stopped the pedal hitting it16. The same thread passes on advice to grease the pedal shaft bushings and fit a new return spring, and replies in other threads list a weak or missing pedal return spring among the causes7,2,17.
When the pushrod is too long, it needs a little free play so the piston can come fully back. That is what the reply on the Galaxie recommended1. Several of these cases followed a new master cylinder or booster: the F250 reply says pedal adjustment is commonly needed after a booster change14, and the Civic thread advises checking this free play before replacing a master cylinder4. A later poster in that thread fought sticky front brakes after changing his master cylinder, concluded its rod was a bit too long, and cured it by fitting a thick muffler gasket behind the master cylinder as a spacer. The next reply describes the proper way: before fitting a new master cylinder, compare its dimensions with the old one, and use one with the correct rod length4. A TR6 owner on the Opel forum had the same after a master cylinder change: the brakes seemed fine, then after a few applications the front wheels locked like a ratchet. Releasing a brake fitting got him home, and a 0.020 inch shim between the master cylinder body and the booster fixed it for good; he cut it U shaped so the master cylinder did not have to come off and be bled again18. Use the figure in the service information for your car. A reply in a Thunderbird thread warned that factory measurements may not apply to an aftermarket master cylinder, and said that on cars he had inherited with modified brakes he set the rod by trial and error8. On the Opel GT the long nut on the pushrod is set so that the rod neither pulls on the pedal nor on the booster, with at most a little play, and the advice there warns that screwing it on too far makes the brakes drag7.
When the booster holds the pushrod forward, it is cleaned or replaced. The 1963 Thunderbird's booster had dried, sticky grease inside, and cleaning and regreasing it cured the slow pedal8. A 1968 LTD's booster kept sticking, and after it was replaced the owner called the brakes incredible19. On the Lada a reply suggested adding a little silicone grease through the booster's filter, and another owner said that had only helped for a while on his own booster, whose pushrod grease had thickened. The original Lada owner first replaced the booster without improvement and later wrote that the booster had been the fault after all, without saying what he changed9.
When the master cylinder itself holds the pressure, it is replaced. The Falcon owner emptied the lines and fitted a new master cylinder, found debris in the ports of the old one, and then ran the car for 20 minutes without the brake lights coming on2. A new master cylinder can be faulty too: the Galaxie reply named a fault in its new master cylinder as the alternative to the pushrod1, and a poster in the Corolla thread had dragging brakes after a master cylinder replacement that went away with a second one11. Some older master cylinders carry a residual check valve at an outlet, which keeps a little pressure in the lines to drum brakes. The Opel GT has one in the outlet to its rear brakes, which on the yellow car are discs7,16. Advice in that thread is split: one source told all Opel owners to remove the valve's internals, while another owner left his intact and has had no trouble7. Whether that valve played a part at Carlisle is not tested in the thread; it is reasoning only that a valve meant to hold pressure for drums sits ahead of discs there.
If the wrong fluid got in, the thorough repair is to replace every rubber part it has reached, which means the master cylinder, the caliper and wheel cylinder seals and the hoses, and then to flush the whole system with the correct fluid. The Lada forum poster who had added power steering fluid did less: he replaced the master cylinder and the fluid, and for him that was enough9.
Any of these repairs that opens the hydraulic system ends with bleeding the brakes, using the scan tool routine on ABS cars that need one, as described on the ABS unit page, and a new master cylinder is bled on the bench before it goes in. Check the result the same careful way as the diagnosis: short, slow runs near home with a temperature check after each, lengthened only while the wheels stay cool, until you have driven well past the distance at which the drag used to appear. A brake that still drags gets hot enough to fade, as a reply about a dragging GMC van warned20.
What owners did
| Car | What was wrong | What was done | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Honda Civic 2002, both fronts | Plug on the pedal missing, brake light switch held the pedal off its stop | Bolt and nut in the pedal hole, switch refitted with the pedal fully back | Brakes fine on a 30 to 40 mile drive4 |
| Car not named, fronts | Pushrod a bit too long after a master cylinder change | Thick muffler gasket fitted behind the master cylinder as a spacer | No more sticky front brakes4 |
| Ford Falcon 1964, drums | Debris in the master cylinder ports | Lines emptied, master cylinder replaced | 20 minutes running with no brake lights coming on2 |
| Ford Thunderbird 1963 | Dried, sticky grease inside the booster, pedal slow to return | Booster cleaned and regreased | Working again8 |
| Ford LTD 1968, front discs | Booster kept sticking | Booster replaced | Brakes much better19 |
| Opel GT | Rears locked at Carlisle, later tied by the owner to the pedal hitting the power steering unit after the front end was raised with spacers | Spacers removed, power steering mounting bolts loosened and repositioned | Pedal no longer hits the unit3,7,16 |
| Lada 21124 2005, fronts | Brakes slow to release, worse with the engine running | Booster replaced, no change at first | Owner later named the booster as the cause9 |
| Car not named, Lada forum | Power steering fluid in the brake reservoir swelled the master cylinder seals | Master cylinder and fluid replaced | Fixed at once9 |
Keeping it from coming back
Several of the cases above began with work on the car, so the best prevention is checking after that work. After a new master cylinder or booster, confirm that the pushrod has its free play and that the pedal comes all the way up by itself1,14. After anything is changed under the dash or in front of the bulkhead, check that the pedal still reaches its stop and that the brake lights go off when you lift your foot4,7. And only ever pour brake fluid of the specified type into the brake reservoir: the power steering fluid mix up on the Lada forum happened because the bottles looked alike9.
Where it comes up most
Many of the reports come from 1960s Fords: a 1963 Galaxie with drums all round and a new master cylinder1, a 1964 Falcon with manual drum brakes and debris in its master cylinder2, a 1963 Thunderbird with old grease in its booster, and a 1964 Thunderbird whose pedal stuck to the floor after its owners went back from a dual master cylinder conversion to the original single one, though that thread reports no drag and no outcome8, and a 1968 LTD with power front discs whose booster kept sticking19. On newer cars the reports involve something keeping the pedal from returning, such as the brake light switch on a 2002 Civic4, or a sticking booster, as on a 2005 Lada 211249. On a Renault Zoe, whose brake had sometimes stuck in the morning when setting off before it failed altogether, the diagnosis was a defective control unit for the brake booster21.
Further reading
Sources
- 63 Galaxie brakes sticking on | Ford Muscle Cars Tech Forum, fordmuscleforums.com
- Brake lights stay on | Ford Automobiles, fordforumsonline.com
- Gordo's Banana Completed??? | Opel GT Forum, opelgt.com
- Sticking Front Brakes, community.cartalk.com
- Brake pressure build up, community.cartalk.com
- Wierd brake problem '96 ford windstar, community.cartalk.com
- Gordo's Banana Completed??? | Page 3 | Opel GT Forum, opelgt.com
- 1964 dual master cylinder conversion problems, forums.fordthunderbirdforum.com
- Очень резкие тормоза, "мягкая" педаль, lada-forum.ru
- Brake problems | Ford Forums, fordforums.com
- '97 Corolla brakes dragging...bleed 'em?, community.cartalk.com
- Brake problem, community.cartalk.com
- Brake lights stay on, community.cartalk.com
- Locked Tires on F250. | Ford Forums, fordforums.com
- Brakes lock up when i gently tap the brake pedal. | Ford Forums, fordforums.com
- Gordo's Banana Completed??? | Page 4 | Opel GT Forum, opelgt.com
- Sticky Brake, community.cartalk.com
- Gordo's Banana Completed??? | Page 2 | Opel GT Forum, opelgt.com
- 68 Galaxie/68 LTD brake similarities? | Ford Automobiles, fordforumsonline.com
- Dragging disk brakes, community.cartalk.com
- Ähnliche Themen, goingelectric.de