Cars and vans › Brakes › Brake drag › Causes

ABS unit holding pressure

A cause of brake drag on cars with anti-lock brakes, traction control or stability control.

Every car with anti-lock brakes has a hydraulic unit, often called the modulator, in the brake lines between the master cylinder and the wheels. On most modern cars it carries a pair of solenoid valves for each wheel: an inlet valve that is open at rest and lets the pressure from the pedal through, and an outlet valve that is closed at rest and, when it opens, lets fluid out of that wheel into a small reservoir from which a pump returns it. Older and simpler systems control the two rear wheels together, and some have anti-lock on the rear wheels only, as a 1990 Ford Aerostar did1. In normal braking none of the valves moves, so the unit is no more than a passage. When a wheel starts to lock, the control unit closes that wheel's inlet valve to hold the pressure and opens its outlet valve to lower it, many times a second. Cars with stability control or traction control also use the unit the other way round: its pump and extra valves can build pressure at a single wheel with no foot on the pedal, which is how these systems brake a wheel that spins or slides.

This gives the unit two ways to make a brake drag. A valve that sticks, or a passage that clogs, can stop the fluid from flowing back out of a wheel when you release the pedal, so the pressure stays trapped in that caliper or wheel cylinder. On a 2018 Ford Kuga 2.5 the wheels locked on a diagonal, and opening the bleed screws let them go only until the next few presses of the pedal; a new hydraulic part for the unit cured it2. The other way is electronic: the control unit, misled by a wrong signal, applies a brake on purpose. On a 2009 Dodge Caravan one wheel kept braking and releasing by itself, without the pedal, while the ABS, ESP and traction control lights were on, and a mechanic found the steering angle sensor telling the computer that the steering wheel was turned fully to the left3. Since the unit is expensive, it pays to rule out the cheaper parts in the same line first; the other causes are in the list of causes.

How it shows up

Because the unit can control each wheel on its own, it can hold one wheel, and because many cars split their brakes into two circuits that each serve one front wheel and the diagonally opposite rear wheel, a fault can also show on a diagonal pair, as on the Kuga2. In most reports it is one wheel: the rear right on two Mercedes Sprinters, a 2001 313 CDI and a 1995 312 D4, the front left on a 1999 Mercury Villager1 and one rear wheel on a 2004 Lincoln Aviator5. When the electronics apply the brakes, several wheels can drag at once: on a 2004 Sprinter 311 CDI 4x4 all four discs were hot after a stretch of motorway driven without touching the brake, the rear ones far hotter than the front, and under full load the van kept losing its pull for a second6.

In several reports the drag began after the ABS had cut in, or after hard or repeated presses of the pedal. The Villager's front left brake stayed on both times after the ABS had cut in during a hard stop or on ice, both times in freezing weather, and the first time the disc was glowing red the next day1. In the same thread the Aerostar's owner describes how its rear brakes locked whenever the anti-lock came on, without the ABS light ever coming on1. On the Sprinter 313 CDI the owner could set off the fault by pumping the pedal hard while standing still, and when a friend drove on with it, the rear brake smoked badly enough that the fire brigade came out and the disc and pads were ruined4. On the Kuga the wheels stayed locked after a few presses of the pedal2.

A warning light may or may not come on. The Villager and the Aerostar never showed one1, while the Caravan had four lights on at once3. On a 2003 Audi A6 the ABS light came on together with a loud clicking from the unit, the car felt as if its brakes were dragging, and the clicking only stopped when the owner disconnected the battery7. A 2004 Subaru Forester swerved now and then as if one front wheel were braking for a moment, and once showed the ABS light; one reply suggested that a stability control system, if the car has one, may be acting on faulty signals8. Not every case with a warning light is the unit. A 2014 VW e-Up twice braked itself when coasting, its brakes got hot and smelled, its consumption rose to 60 to 80 kWh per 100 km, the ESC light came on with a message that the city emergency braking had failed, and the workshop found an entry from the ABS in the fault memory; pressing the brake pedal hard several times freed it9. Its owner wondered about ice in the brakes or a fault in the ABS, while a reply argued that a mechanical brake had seized from rust, since an electric car uses its friction brakes so rarely, and that the ABS had only switched itself off in response; the cause was not found in the thread9.

Telling it apart from other causes

The first step is to prove that the brake is being held by pressure. While the brake is dragging, open the bleed screw on that wheel. If the wheel frees as soon as the screw is open, the brake was being held by pressure from further up: the master cylinder side, the ABS unit, a rear pressure regulator or a hose. This is what owners found on the Kuga, the Aviator and two Sprinters2,5,4. If the wheel still drags with the screw open, the fault is at the wheel itself, for example a stuck piston or seal, pads stuck in the carrier or seized slide pins. How much fluid comes out does not decide it; whether the wheel frees does. Close the screw at once, top up the reservoir and bleed that brake before the car moves. The test only works while the brake is dragging.

From the pedal to the wheel, the parts that can hold the pressure are the pedal and brake light switch, the booster and its pushrod, the master cylinder, the ABS unit, for the rear brakes a rear pressure regulator or proportioning valve, and the flexible hose, before the caliper or wheel cylinder; whether the ABS unit or the regulator comes first varies by car. To find which of them holds it, open the joints one at a time, from the wheel upwards. The brake has to be dragging again before each step, because every opened joint lets the pressure go. A wheel that frees at once when a joint is opened clears everything between that joint and the wheel. A part that lets pressure back only slowly can still let the brake go a while after a joint further up is opened, so a wheel that frees slowly clears nothing. The owner of the 1995 Sprinter 312 D worked this way with the engine off, pressing the pedal again before each step: the pressure went when he opened the bleed screw, again when he opened the line at the outlet of the load-sensing regulator at the rear axle, and again at its inlet, which left the ABS unit and the master cylinder as the next parts up4. He does not say how quickly the wheel freed, and releasing pressure at the regulator's inlet does not clear a regulator that lets pressure back slowly. That is how a Sprinter W903 misled its owner: the rear right brake let go when he opened its line at the ABS unit, yet the culprit was the regulator, which let pressure through but released it not at all or only very slowly10. No owner describes a test that tells such a regulator apart from a sticking valve in the ABS unit. A reply in the 312 D thread gives the next two steps: open the wheel's line at the ABS unit, and if the brake frees there, lock it again and open the line at the master cylinder; if the wheel frees at the master cylinder too, the unit is not holding the pressure4. On the Kuga, mechanics likewise suggested loosening the master cylinder line for that circuit, since a compensating port that does not open holds pressure as well2. The owner of the 313 CDI went the other way, replacing the hose and blowing the line from the unit to the caliper through with compressed air, and when neither helped he concluded that the unit was at fault4. Tighten each joint straight away, and bleed the brakes afterwards; air near the unit is hard to bleed out, so ABS cars that need it get the scan tool routine described under Repairing it below.

Taking power away from the unit shows whether it is involved, though not which part of it. The Kuga braked normally with the unit unpowered and the engine off, but powered, its wheels stayed locked after a few presses, and commanding the valves from a scan tool released them, again only for a few presses2; yet the fault turned out to be hydraulic. On the Sprinter 311 CDI 4x4 the owner pulled the 40 A fuse in the driver's seat box, drove the same motorway test, and found all four discs only hand warm, and the judder under full load gone; with the fuse back in, the discs were hot again6. A brake that frees when the unit is unpowered therefore points to the unit or the signals it receives. A brake that still drags does not clear the unit, because a valve that is mechanically stuck does not care about power: the Aviator still dragged with the ABS connector unplugged, which left its owner suspecting something inside the unit acting like a check valve5, and a 1998 Toyota 4Runner still locked its right front wheel after the pedal was released with the ABS fuse pulled11; neither cause was found. The unit may have more than one fuse. In the 4x4 thread one owner wrote that pulling the wrong one on his own van stopped the speedometer, and another that the 40 A fuse feeds only the return pump, with separate fuses for the wheel speed sensors and the rest of the control unit, and that pulling it at a standstill changed nothing on his van6; and on a VW LT the 60 A fuse in the driver's seat box switches off the whole ABS including its traction function12. Without the fuse the car has no ABS or stability control, so this is a test, not a way to keep driving.

Read the fault memory with a tool that can read ABS codes, because the basic code readers lent out by parts stores often cannot13,14. Where the codes or the unpowered test point to an input, look at that input before the unit. On the Sprinter 4x4 a reply traced the same automatic braking on his own van to an ABS tone ring bent while the wheel bearings were changed, which made the wheel speed reading wrong so that the ABS and traction control stepped in; he suggested watching the wheel speeds on a diagnostic tool at low speed, where a bent ring shows as a dip once per turn of the wheel6. On the Caravan, one reply explained that steering angle sensor faults are common on Chrysler products after the battery has been disconnected with the wheels not pointing straight, and that a scan tool recalibrates the sensor at the press of a button3. Do not mistake normal behaviour for a fault: the 4x4's owner ran the rear wheels on a lift and felt them braked hard, which he later understood to be the traction control doing its job6.

Repairing it

A brake held on by the unit produces a lot of heat, and the reports show a disc glowing red and a van smoking on the motorway1,4. Do not drive the car while it drags. The e-Up owner was told by other drivers to leave the car where it was and have it towed to the dealer9.

When the cause is an input, such as a wheel speed sensor, a bent tone ring or a steering angle sensor that needs calibrating, repairing that input is the fix and the unit can stay. The Caravan's owner instead pulled the ABS pump and valve fuses, after which the wheel stopped braking by itself, and kept driving the van that way with all the warning lights on and, as it turned out, a dead speedometer3; that leaves the car without ABS and stability control and is no repair.

When the hydraulic part of the unit holds the pressure, owners have had it cleaned, repaired or replaced. On the Aerostar a tyre shop's brake technician recognised the fault on a short drive in the car park, cleaned the valve and flushed the brake lines, and the problem did not come back1. On the 1995 Sprinter 312 D a mechanic suggested a full stop hard enough to make the ABS cycle, in case a control valve was hanging; that freed the brake, but after about 10 km it locked again4. The Kuga's unit is rare and costs about 170,000 roubles; a specialist instead fitted another hydraulic part and kept the original electronics for 42,000 roubles, and afterwards the brakes worked2. The owner of the Sprinter 313 CDI was looking for a used unit, since 800 or 1,500 euros was more than he could spend4. Repair services for failed units exist, though the reports of them come from units that had failed in other ways. In a Sprinter thread that began with a unit showing return pump and pressure sensor faults, whose outcome is not reported, one owner said he had sent his whole block to a specialist, who repaired it for about 160 euros, and another found a magnet stuck on a valve and moisture inside his unit, which the repairer called not repairable; he fitted a used unit with the same Mercedes and Bosch numbers, recoded for his van, and it worked15. The same thread warns that a replacement must carry the same number as the original15. A repair is not always for good: the service that overhauled the 313 CDI's unit after an earlier fault warned that it would start leaking again4.

Fitting a new or repaired unit opens the hydraulic system, so it ends with bleeding. Air trapped inside the unit is hard to reach by ordinary bleeding, so on many cars a scan tool has to run the unit's valves and pump during the job. On the Kuga thread a mechanic noted that a Land Rover's scan tool asks for a pressure bleeding device and walks through the steps2, the Aviator's owner ordered a scan tool with an ABS bleed function5, the Sprinter 4x4's owner planned to have Mercedes run the ABS bleeding program again6, and a Buick Century owner who took his modulator out kept it upright so that fluid would not run out and leave air in it that normal bleeding would not purge16. Afterwards, check on a short drive that every wheel turns freely and stays cool.

What owners did

CarWhat was wrongWhat was doneResult
Ford Kuga 2.5 2018Wheels locking on a diagonal after a few pedal presses, normal with the unit unpoweredHydraulic part of the unit replaced, original electronics keptBrakes worked normally2
Ford Aerostar 1990, rearRear brakes locked whenever the rear anti-lock came onTyre shop cleaned a gummed-up valve and flushed the brake linesNo more problems1
Mercedes Sprinter 313 CDI 2001, rear rightPressure held after hard pedal pumping; unit overhauled the year beforeNew caliper and hose, line blown through with compressed airNo change; owner concluded the ABS unit was at fault4
Mercedes Sprinter 312 D 1995, rear rightPressure held after winter storage; released at the bleed screw and on both sides of the rear regulatorNew caliper, then a full ABS stopFreed, but locked again after about 10 km4
Mercedes Sprinter 311 CDI 4x4 2004All four discs hot without braking, rear far hotter; cold with the 40 A ABS fuse pulledABS bleed program planned; a reply suspected a bent tone ringNot reported6
Lincoln Aviator 2004 AWD, rearDrag moved from side to side after bleedingCalipers, discs, pads, hoses and master cylinder replaced; ABS unpluggedStill dragging, ABS unit next5
VW e-Up 2014Car braked itself when coasting, ABS entry in the fault memoryBrake pedal pressed hard several timesFreed for the time; cause not found9
Dodge Caravan 2009One wheel braking by itself; steering angle sensor reading full left lockABS pump and valve fuses pulledBraking stopped; warning lights on, speedometer dead3

Keeping it from coming back

Brake fluid absorbs water from the air, which is why makers set an interval for changing it2. Owners suspect that this water is what makes the valves stick, though in the threads this is only a guess10.

Several cases began with brake work. The Kuga's trouble started after a caliper was replaced and the brakes were bled the old way, by pedal, and owners in that thread report that bleeding with the scan tool helps2; one Sprinter owner recalls a VW T4 whose ABS held the car after a pad change, which only let go once the ABS fuse was pulled4. Bleed the unit as the car's procedure requires after any work that may let air into it. A further precaution follows from this, though no report shows it preventing a stuck valve: when you push the pistons back to fit new pads, open the bleed screw so that the old fluid goes out rather than back up the line, as one mechanic advises for brake work in general17.

Where it comes up most

Several reports come from first-generation Mercedes Sprinter vans: the owners of a 1995 312 D and a 2001 313 CDI suspected the unit without confirming it4, and on a 2004 311 CDI 4x4 the brakes stopped dragging with the unit's fuse pulled6. On the Ford Kuga, one mechanic called a diagonal lock from the unit some kind of Kuga ailment, and another agreed2.

Further reading

Sources

  1. Brake seized 2 times in 2 months, community.cartalk.com
  2. Ford Kuga 2.5 2018 ремонт блока АБС, forum.adact.ru
  3. Brake Problem, community.cartalk.com
  4. Bremse hängt, Druck in der Leitung geht nicht weg..., sprinter-forum.de
  5. 2004 Aviator rear brake dragging mystery | Ford Forums, fordforums.com
  6. Schlagendes /schleifendes Geräusch v. Hinterachse - ABS/ESP schuld?, sprinter-forum.de
  7. 2003 Audi A6 ...need help? | Audi Forums, audi-forums.com
  8. 2004 Subaru Forester Swerves, community.cartalk.com
  9. Ähnliche Themen, goingelectric.de
  10. Betriebsbremse hängt fest, sprinter-forum.de
  11. '98 4Runner RF Break Locks and Won't Release, community.cartalk.com
  12. Elektrische Tractionskontrolle(ABD), sprinter-forum.de
  13. ABS light, community.cartalk.com
  14. ABS Light stays on, community.cartalk.com
  15. 903 308 CDI ABS Steuergerät kompatibilität?, sprinter-forum.de
  16. Can I replace ruptured rear brake line 2000 Century?, community.cartalk.com
  17. Dragging disk brakes, community.cartalk.com