Cars and vans › Brakes › Brake drag › Causes

Pads stuck in the carrier or clips

A cause of brake drag on disc brakes, where the pads slide in guides on the caliper carrier or the caliper itself.

In a disc brake the brake pads are not bolted in place. The ends of each pad's steel backing plate sit in guides in the caliper carrier (also called the anchor bracket), or in the caliper itself, and on many cars they ride on thin stainless steel clips or guide plates clipped onto those guides. When you brake, the piston pushes the pads against the disc, and when you let go, the piston seal draws the piston back a fraction of a millimetre and the spinning disc pushes the pads back by the same small amount. That release only works if the pads can slide freely in their guides. The guide surfaces are bare steel, so rust grows on them and underneath the clips, and since rust takes up more room than the steel it came from, the gap around the pad slowly closes until the pad is wedged. The owner of a 2017 VW Crafter described exactly this: the pads were jammed in the carrier by corrosion so tightly that the service brake pressed them against the disc and they could not return to their starting position afterwards, so they stayed in contact and rubbed 1.

The pads themselves can be the problem as well. On a Mercedes Sprinter the original pads had swollen and no longer moved freely in their guide plates 2. Either way the hydraulics are fine and the fault sits at the wheel itself. It can affect a single pad, and in the reports below it also turns up on both sides of an axle and on all four wheels.

How it shows up

In the reports, owners noticed a noise and a warm wheel first. On a Sprinter the rim at the rear left was warm while the other three stayed cooler, and there was a high-pitched whistle on the motorway; the cause was the inner pad hanging in its rusty guides 3. Another Sprinter owner, whose van stands for long periods, had a squeal and a rear left wheel that ran warmer than the others, and a reply from an owner with the same fault on the right side named guide plates seized by rust and brake dust 1. The swollen Sprinter pads first made a grinding noise and later a squeal 2. In the same thread as the Crafter, an owner who found the pads and carriers rusted on all four wheels after a winter noticed it through squealing brakes and a fuel consumption about two litres higher than usual 1.

Left long enough, a pad that cannot move wears out much faster than its partner. On 1999 to 2001 VW Golf and Jetta models owners report the rear pads wearing out before the fronts, several of them the inner pad on the rear passenger side. One 1999 Golf owner who took the brake apart found the sliders on both sides moving smoothly, but the pads jammed in the carrier and the stainless clips they ride on caked with dirt. Other owners in the same thread blamed crud on the caliper sliders instead, which is the fault described under seized slide pins 4. Another 2001 Golf owner says his rear pads were dragging because of crud on those clips 5. On a Renault Twizy whose rear pads were worn out after about 8,000 km, one reply put it down to pads that seize in their guides, do not come away from the disc and keep rubbing, while another blamed rust on discs that are rarely used 6. A badly worn inner pad can also hide from a quick look, whatever wore it down: on a Sprinter whose pad wear warning came on now and then and later stayed on, the owner checked the pads through the holes in the steel wheels with a torch and thought they were all thick enough, and only found the badly worn inner pad at the rear left after taking every pad out. That poster did not say why the pad had worn 3.

Seized pads can also turn up at an inspection rather than as drag. At a German vehicle inspection a VW LT35 was faulted because the rear brakes differed by more than 25 percent between left and right and because its rear brake load-sensing valve was stuck. The owner found the rear pads somewhat seized because they were very old, and treated the stuck valve as the main problem; the thread does not say which of the two caused the difference 7.

Telling it apart from other causes

First make sure the brake really is dragging, by comparing wheel temperatures after a drive as described under Is it really dragging?. A noise alone is a weak sign. A Sprinter motorhome made a loud grinding noise when braking after ten to fifteen minutes of driving, a reply suggested pads rusted in their guides, and in the end the cause was rust on the discs from standing for weeks, which went away by itself 8. Squeal in particular has other causes: on a 1980 Toyota Cressida with new pads, replies suggested missing anti-squeal clips, the pad compound and the old discs, and one asked whether the calipers were releasing, since a dragging caliper is noisy too 9. A slightly dragging pad can squeal too, though: for an intermittent chirp on a 2004 Camry after new front pads, the first reply suspected pads dragging lightly and asked whether grease had gone on their backs, and others pointed to Toyota's own pads and shims; the thread ends without an answer 10. The heat at the wheel, not the sound, decides.

Next, rule out pressure being held further up. The test only works while the brake is dragging: open the bleed screw on that wheel. If the wheel frees as soon as the screw is open, the brake was being held by pressure from further up the line, which runs from the pedal and master cylinder side through the ABS unit where fitted and, for the rear brakes, a pressure regulator, to the flexible hose; whether the ABS unit or the regulator comes first varies by car. If the wheel still drags with the screw open, the fault is at the wheel itself, where stuck pads are one candidate. How much fluid comes out does not decide it; whether the wheel frees does. Close the screw at once, top up the reservoir and bleed that brake before the car moves. A 2002 Honda Civic shows why this matters. Both front brakes dragged. The owner lubricated the pad guides and felt an improvement that lasted only a short test drive, and from then on opening the front bleeders let him drive on. New hoses, new pads with new clips, greased pins, a fluid flush and finally new calipers all left the brakes still dragging. The cause was the brake pedal: a brake light switch pushed in without regard to the pedal's position kept the pedal from returning fully, and once the switch was refitted with the pedal right back, the brakes worked properly after a 30 to 40 mile drive 11. That is the master cylinder side not returning, and it is why relief from cleaning that does not last is a sign to look further up the system.

The direct test is to take the pads out. A pad that is stuck in its guides needs force to come out, and a good pad goes back in by hand; a Sprinter owner put it simply: what matters is that the pads go in easily 8. Look at the guide surfaces, at whether the clips or guide plates are lifted or crusted, and at the ends of the pad backing plates. With the pads out you can check the neighbouring faults at the same time. On a floating caliper, slide the caliper on its slide pins, since seized slide pins give very similar uneven wear, and the same Sprinter reply advised checking both 8. Push the piston back: if it is very hard to move, that points to a stuck piston or seal. A 2004 Sprinter owner with hot rear wheels suspected dirty pistons, and a reply pointed out that pads always touch the disc lightly, but that a wheel running warmer means something is hanging, and that the hooks at the ends of the pad backing plates sometimes jam in the caliper 12.

At the rear, the parking brake needs checking as well, because on many cars it works through the same caliper and pads. A mechanic told the owner of a 2009 Fiat (type 198) with a stiff rear left wheel to replace the brake drum, but the car has no drum: its handbrake acts through the caliper, and a reply listed a pad stuck in the caliper, a seized piston or a rusted parking brake lever shaft on the caliper as the candidates 13. In a VW TDI thread, a parking brake cable that has let water in and frozen or rusted was suggested before suspecting the pads 4. Disconnecting the cable tells a sticking cable from a sticking caliper, but not the pads from the caliper's own parking mechanism, since a rusted lever shaft keeps holding with the cable off; that needs the pads out and the lever moved by hand.

Repairing it

The repair does not open the hydraulic system. With the wheel off, take the caliper off the carrier and hang it from the suspension with wire or a hook, never by its hose 14. On the Sprinter, one poster described undoing the lower bolt and swinging the caliper up, and gave 28 Nm for that bolt on reassembly 8; other cars differ, so use the figure for your own. Take the pads out, then clean every surface a pad touches down to bare metal. The Sprinter owner with the hot rear left wheel scraped the rusty guides clean, filed them and greased them, refitted pads and caliper, and the rim stopped heating up and the noise on the motorway went away 3. The Crafter owner removed the rust from the carrier where the pads touch it and fitted a new set of pads with their fitting kit 1. On a 1999 Golf the clips were cleaned with brake cleaner and emery cloth, coated thinly with grease, and a small dab of grease went on the notch of each backing plate where it rides on the clip 4.

Clips or guide plates that are bent, worn or crusted underneath are best replaced, as the owner with the swollen pads did together with discs and pads 2. Old pads that are seized or swollen go as well; the Sprinter poster's rule was to replace pads that are below half their thickness while the wheels are off anyway 8, and on the LT35 the owner cleaned the caliper completely and fitted new pads 7. The owner whose pads and carriers had rusted on all four wheels found them hard to free, gave the pads more play by adapting them to the carrier and used plenty of copper paste to keep it from happening again 1; others suggest copper paste or a light coat of grease on the pad ends and hooks, kept off the friction surface 8,12. The different lubricants owners use are discussed under seized slide pins.

New pads are thicker than worn ones, so the piston has to go back into its bore. On rear calipers with the parking brake built in, it has to be turned back while it is pushed, not just pressed in, and one owner warns against tearing the rubber dust seal around the piston while doing it, since a torn seal eventually ruins the caliper 1,5. With an electric parking brake the caliper motor has to be released first, as described under stuck piston or seal. Afterwards pump the pedal until it is firm before moving the car, check the other side of the axle, which on the Crafter was in almost the same state 1, and after a short drive compare wheel temperatures again. If the wheel still runs hot, the pads were not the whole story.

What owners did

CarWhat was wrongWhat was doneResult
Mercedes Sprinter, rear leftInner pad hanging in rusty guides, warm rim, whistle at speedGuides scraped clean, filed and greasedRim no longer heats up, noise gone3
VW Crafter 2017, rear leftPads wedged in the carrier by corrosion, kept rubbingCarrier contact points derusted, new pads with fitting kit, piston wound backReported as the repair; right side nearly as bad1
Van not named, all four wheelsPads and carriers rusted after winter, squeal, fuel use up by about 2 lPads fitted to the carrier for more play, copper pasteNot reported1
Mercedes SprinterOriginal pads swollen, stuck in the guide platesDiscs, pads and guide plates replacedQuiet again2
VW Golf 1999, rearPads jammed in the carrier, clips caked with dirtClips cleaned with brake cleaner and emery, thin greaseNot reported4
VW LT35, rearOld pads partly seized, braking unequal at inspectionCaliper cleaned, new pads, piston worked in and outNot reported7
Honda Civic 2002, frontBoth fronts dragging; pad guides suspected firstPad guides lubricated; later hoses, pads, clips and calipers replacedShort relief only; cured by refitting the brake light switch so the pedal returned11

Keeping it from coming back

Rust is what jams the pads, and standing and winter make it worse. One Sprinter owner says the rear brakes sometimes stick, especially in winter, and the van with the warm rear left wheel was one that is rarely driven 1. One reply on the Sprinter forum says pads usually rust in their guides and advises taking them out regularly and scraping the guides and the pad ends clean 15, and every pad change is the natural time to clean the guides, fit new clips where the kit has them and put a thin film of grease on the contact points 1,4. Another calls the rear left a weak spot of the Sprinter and suspects it is because that side faces the traffic and gets more spray from passing cars; that is his guess, though most of the Sprinter and Crafter reports here are indeed from the rear left 3. For the Renault Twizy, one owner's advice is to clean the brakes regularly with a pressure washer, and he names a conversion of the brake pistons as the other remedy 6; Twizy front pistons that corrode are described under stuck piston or seal.

Where it comes up most

Most of the reports collected here come from the Mercedes Sprinter, with one from a VW Crafter, mainly at the rear, with pads seized in rusty guides or guide plates 3,1,2. The other cluster is the rear brakes of 1999 to 2001 VW Golf, Jetta and New Beetle TDIs, where owners report rear pads wearing out before the fronts; one found the pads stuck in the carrier and cruddy carrier clips, while others in the same thread put it down to the sliders. One owner says VW replaced his rear pads free under a service bulletin at 41,000 km and that they had been stuck in the carrier, while other posters there connect the bulletin with soft rear pads instead 4,5. On the Renault Twizy one owner calls it a design fault that the pads seize in their guides, then do not come away from the disc properly and keep rubbing, and says Renault is generous with goodwill when asked 6.

Further reading

Sources

  1. Bremsen hinten links - Geräusch und Wärmeentwicklung, sprinter-forum.de
  2. Schleifgeräusche beim Beschleunigen, sprinter-forum.de
  3. Bremsbelag Verschleißanzeige trotz Bremse Kabel iO, sprinter-forum.de
  4. rear passenger wheel - stuck and brake pad worn out, forums.tdiclub.com
  5. rear brake piston reset, forums.tdiclub.com
  6. Ähnliche Themen, goingelectric.de
  7. ALB gängig machen, sprinter-forum.de
  8. Heftige Schleifgeräusche beim Bremsen, sprinter-forum.de
  9. Old Toyotas and squeaky brakes, community.cartalk.com
  10. If it's not the brake wear indicators, community.cartalk.com
  11. Sticking Front Brakes, community.cartalk.com
  12. hintere Bremse schleift/klemmt, sprinter-forum.de
  13. Hilfe bremstrommel, fiat-forum.de
  14. "Underdesigned" Brakes Likely Causing Problem (Newspaper Column), community.cartalk.com
  15. Bremsenproblem am Sprinter 212 D, sprinter-forum.de